Blue Archipelago

11 Jun, 2008

Book Review | Something Borrowed by Emily Giffin

Posted by: Clare Swindlehurst In: 3 stars| 50 book challenge| Challenges| Chick Lit Challenge| Reviews| Spring Reading Thing| Summer Reading

Something Borrowed - Buy this Book [US]

Rating

3.5 stars - would keep you occupied on the beach

Description

Something Borrowed tells the story of Rachel, a young attorney living and working in Manhattan. Rachel has always been the consummate good girl - until her thirtieth birthday, when her best friend, Darcy, throws her a party. That night, after too many drinks, Rachel ends up in bed with Darcy’s fiancé.

Why did you choose to read this book

It’s been sitting on my TBR shelf for a long time and the Chick Lit challenge seemed to be a good enough reason to dust it off and read it!

The Book Review

Something Borrowed is Emily Giffin’s first novel - and the exclamations from other authors printed on the cover set the bar high. According to Marian Keyes she read it in two sittings as she loved it and couldn’t put it down. I too read this book in two sittings - a train journey to a meeting and then a train journey home - but I can’t say that I loved it. Don’t get me wrong - it’s a good book - with a story line that makes you think about friendship, relationships and betrayal - but I have a feeling that if I hadn’t been a captive audience I might have got a little bored.

This book came in a bundle with Something Blue - the sequel - which I think is the same story told from the perspective of the cheating boyfriend - I’ll give that one a try next month and let you know what I think.

Have you reviewed this book?

If you have reviewed this book on your site please fill in the boxes below to link me up to your review - don’t forget to link to the specific post to make it easy to find:

Zemanta Pixie

Have you started your Christmas shopping yet? Here are some Christmas Gift ideas you might find useful.

Related posts:

  1. Book Review | The God of Animals by Aryn Kyle
  2. Book Review | Matrimony by Josh Henkin
  3. Book Review | The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time by Mark Haddon
  4. Book Review | Through a Glass, Darkly by Jostein Gaarder
  5. Book Review | Perfect on Paper by Maria Murnane

8 Responses to "Book Review | Something Borrowed by Emily Giffin"

1 | Marg

June 11th, 2008 at 8:50 pm

Avatar

I’ve linked to my review of this book!

Margs last blog post..Kids are expensive!

2 | Kristen

June 11th, 2008 at 9:59 pm

Avatar

Hi! I completely agree with your review — and actually liked Something Blue better. My absolute Giffin favorite is Baby Proof, though. With Somthing Borrowed I had a hard time getting past the infidelity and the idea that what the “hero” did was supposedly justified by the fact that Darcy was “difficult” and didn’t belong with her fiance. Cheatin’ is cheatin’ no matter how you try to explain it away! :) Great review, though!

3 | Trish

June 11th, 2008 at 11:32 pm

Avatar

I’ve seen her books around a lot recently, but I haven’t had a real desire to pick one up (same thing with the Kinsella novels). They seem like they would be great vacation or beach reads.

Trishs last blog post..Something Wicked This Way Comes - Ray Bradbury

Trishs last blog post..Something Wicked This Way Comes - Ray Bradbury

4 | Mrs S

June 12th, 2008 at 6:58 am

Avatar

Hey Marg - I read your review - you covered all the points I would have if I’d taken time to write a proper review - the book just didn’t inspire me enough to spend the time!

Kristen - I think that’s why it didn’t sit quite right - the people doing the cheating had the happy ending and that’s not right! Over on Marg’s blog I confessed that I’d rather the ending hadn’t been a happy one and that Rachel’s first cooked dinner was interrupted by a policeman arriving at the door to announce an accident of some sort!

5 | Alix

June 12th, 2008 at 10:05 pm

Avatar

This is on my TBR list, I did wonder about the cheating aspect but I guess people do cheat and some of them have happy ever afters.
Thanks for the review

Alixs last blog post..WG 7 - The Photo Post

Alixs last blog post..WG 7 - The Photo Post

6 | raidergirl3

July 7th, 2008 at 3:35 am

Avatar

Somthing Blue is from Darcy’s point of view, but it also continues the story. It’s not just a side by side of the events of the first book. I actually preferred Something Borrowed

raidergirl3s last blog post..Welcome

7 | Mrs S

July 7th, 2008 at 7:05 pm

Avatar

Hi Raidergirl3 - I realised that myself yesterday when I picked the book up to relegate it to the TBR someday probably never pile! Having found that it is not the same story from another viewpoint I’ve decided to give it a go after all - though I would have been happier if you’d have preferred blue!

Comment Form


  • Jessica: I'm loving the new format. I loved your other one too, but I understand about the "tired" thing. I love my theme, but I think it needs some revampin
  • Kimberlyy: I'm In Love With Twilight, I Saw The Moviee And Thought It Was Amazingg<33 When I Heard About The Frist Chapter Of Midnight Sunn I Went To Her Web
  • Jessi: I'm not familiar with the service, but it sounds wonderful! Thanks for sharing. :) Jessi´s last blog post..

About Blue Archipelago

I'm working my way through 75 books this year - and writing a review of each one as I finish it. You can share your thoughts in the comments section.

My rating system

5/5 Loved it - highly recommended
4/5 Enjoyed it - can recommend
3/5 Okay - not too exciting
2/5 Not worth the effort
1/5 Hated it
0/5 Didn't even finish it


The chatty corner