Blue Archipelago

19 Apr, 2008

Book Review | Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult

Posted by: Clare Swindlehurst In: 5 stars| 50 book challenge| Spring Reading Thing| The Pub (2008)

Nineteen Minutes - Buy this book
Nineteen Minutes - Buy this book

Rating

5 stars - Picoult at her best

Description - from jodipicoult.com

In Sterling, New Hampshire, 17-year-old high school student Peter Houghton has endured years of verbal and physical abuse at the hands of classmates. His best friend, Josie Cormier, succumbed to peer pressure and now hangs out with the popular crowd that often instigates the harassment. One final incident of bullying sends Peter over the edge and leads him to commit an act of violence that forever changes the lives of Sterling’s residents.

Why did you choose to read this book?

I’ve been a fan of Picout’s ever since reading My Sister’s Keeper - and have been waiting in avid anticipation for this latest book to be released in paperback for what seems like forever!

The book review

It’s been a while since I read one of Picoult’s books - and I’d forgotten how much I enjoy her writing style. This one is a series of flash backs through different period’s of Peter’s life, revealing different events in the run up to the day he fought back against the bullies who had made his life such a misery. Within each chapter we see events through the eyes of the different characters, Peter and Josie, the children’s parents, the lawyer and the police detective. Sometimes Picoult switches between two or three characters over a matter of one or two pages, but it is never confusing as each character has such a strong voice that you identify with from the outset.

Readers of The Pact, Salem Falls and Perfect Match will recognise two of the characters, Jordan McAfee and Patrick Ducharme as they make a reappearance here.

This book covers some hard-hitting issues, but I think Picoult covers them in a very sensitive and thought provoking way. This latest offering is a joy to read and I would certainly recommend it to anyone, regardless of whether it would be your first Picoult novel, or you are a fan like me.

Book exploration - CAUTION SPOILER ALERT

Did you like the way the book ended?

I enjoyed this book from the very first page, I liked the way Picoult led us back and forth through periods of time to learn about Peter and Josie’s relationship, and to help us identify key events in their lives that could have led up to the fateful day that Peter entered the school with a bag full of weapons. I could sense there was a twist, and guessed early on what it could be, but I had to wait almost until the end to be proved right.

I’m not sure I liked the outcome of the book though; once Josie confessed it seemed to be a done deal that Peter would be convicted - if it had been Matt holding the gun as Josie first suggested would McAfee’s beaten wife syndrome have stood up as a defence? We don’t get to see anything of Josie’s trial - but surely that would have been her defence too? After all she’d found herself trapped in a violent relationship; trapped because she wanted everyone to think she was popular, but more worryingly, because Matt had a violent streak. Did she find herself with a gun in her hand and escape on the horizon?

The events of this novel are certainly food for thought - though the main focus is on Peter and how the constant taunting and bullying by the popular kids drove him to react in the worst possible way - I was also interested in Josie’s *plight*, being in the popular crowd, but not fitting in. I wonder how events would have turned out if Alex hadn’t caught the children with a shotgun in hand and they had been allowed to remain friends…

Have you reviewed this book?

If you have reviewed this book on your site please fill in the boxes below to link me up to your review - don’t forget to link to the specific post to make it easy to find:

Introducing thisbookforfree.com

Thanks to Dewy at The Hidden Side of a Leaf I discovered a new site today - thisbookforfree.com. The site is owned by Shoshana - and she is giving away all kinds of books for free!

One of her latest contests is to win your favourite author’s next release - so I thought I would enter for a chance to win Second Glance which is being released in paperback in the summer.

If you’ve got some spare time today why not stop by and see if you can win yourself some free books too.

Have you started your Christmas shopping yet? Here are some Christmas Gift ideas you might find useful.

Related posts:

  1. Book Review | Second Glance by Jodi Picoult
  2. Aside | Please vote for me!
  3. Book Review | March by Geraldine Brooks
  4. Book Review | The Girl Who Stopped Swimming by Joshilyn Jackson
  5. Book review | Secrets of a Family Album by Isla Dewar

9 Responses to "Book Review | Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult"

1 | Linda Jacobs

April 19th, 2008 at 4:18 pm

Avatar

I have to say I agree with you about the ending. It was a bit abrupt. But the whole message was superb. I teach high school English and this should be required reading!

Linda Jacobs’s last blog post..Prose + Poetry = A Winner!

2 | Trish

April 19th, 2008 at 8:26 pm

Avatar

This one was not one of my favorites, but I still found myself lost in the story. I also read it right after the Virginia Tech shootings (not sure how much of the coverage you got across the ocean), so it seemed especially powerful. I haven’t read her newest yet, but I think I might squeeze it in the next couple of weeks. Hasn’t gotten the best of reviews, but oh well!

Trish’s last blog post..A Million Little Pieces - James Frey

3 | Mrs S

April 20th, 2008 at 7:52 am

Avatar

@Linda - I would think this would make an excellent book for High School English as it would open up a debate about issues close to student’s hearts - in fact the link to the book discussion questions at the end of the article also has a section on how to use the book with students.

@Trish - I can imagine that reading it after the events of Virginia Tech would have made it hit home even more. Her newest just hit the shelves here - in hardback - I did look longingly at it in the store on Friday - but I resisted! I really would rather read the paperback - and I figured its probably not a good idea to read two of hers so close together.

4 | Shoshana

April 27th, 2008 at 12:02 am

Avatar

Hi Mrs. S, yeah, this contest is open everywhere amazon delivers.

Thank you for joining!

Shoshana’s last blog post..Available Books

5 | Shoshana

April 27th, 2008 at 12:05 am

Avatar

I read this book, and I remember liking it a lot. I wasn’t sure I like the ending though…but it’s worth reading for sure.

I like My Sister’s Keeper. I’m effy on the ending too.

Shoshana’s last blog post..Photo Hunt: Signs

6 | Mrs S

April 27th, 2008 at 8:35 am

Avatar

Hi Shoshana - now I know your name! Thanks for stopping by :) My Sister’s Keeper is definitely my favourite Picoult too - that one is hard to beat.

7 | Kristen

May 3rd, 2008 at 7:17 pm

Avatar

I think I did this right! But just in case, here’s the link to my review: http://bookclubclassics.com/Blog/2007/11/18/nineteen-minutes/

I’m looking forward to your review of March!

8 | Mrs S

May 4th, 2008 at 7:28 am

Avatar

@Kristen - looks right to me - I’m off to read your review now!

Comment Form


  • Jessica: I'm loving the new format. I loved your other one too, but I understand about the "tired" thing. I love my theme, but I think it needs some revampin
  • Kimberlyy: I'm In Love With Twilight, I Saw The Moviee And Thought It Was Amazingg<33 When I Heard About The Frist Chapter Of Midnight Sunn I Went To Her Web
  • Jessi: I'm not familiar with the service, but it sounds wonderful! Thanks for sharing. :) Jessi´s last blog post..

About Blue Archipelago

I'm working my way through 75 books this year - and writing a review of each one as I finish it. You can share your thoughts in the comments section.

My rating system

5/5 Loved it - highly recommended
4/5 Enjoyed it - can recommend
3/5 Okay - not too exciting
2/5 Not worth the effort
1/5 Hated it
0/5 Didn't even finish it


The chatty corner